| Dimension | Scoring Notes | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Study Design | Well-executed preclinical work: patch-clamp electrophysiology on human TREK-1 channels plus validated rodent behavioral models (forced swim, novelty-suppressed feeding) with appropriate controls. Methodology is sound for what it is, but the entire base is animal and in vitro. |
12 / 25 |
| Sample Size | Small rodent cohorts and cell-line assays. No human sample of any size. |
3 / 20 |
| Replication | Findings come almost entirely from the single originating laboratory. Minimal independent replication exists. |
2 / 20 |
| Journal Impact Factor | Published in venues such as Frontiers in Pharmacology, with the parent spadin work in PLoS Biology. Mixed mid-tier. |
5 / 15 |
| Funding Independence | Academic (French public research / CNRS), but concentrated in the one group that also holds the intellectual-property interest in the spadin / TREK-1 antidepressant line. Single-group concentration is the main constraint. |
3 / 10 |
| Population Diversity | No human populations; rodent models only. |
0 / 5 |
| Researcher h-Index | The originating group is credible in the TREK-1 niche but does not carry a top-tier citation profile in broader neuroscience. |
2 / 5 |